There is a scholarly perspective suggesting that Paul might be quoting a cultural or traditional view in 1 Corinthians 14:34-35 and then refuting it in verse 36. This interpretation hinges on the idea that Paul is addressing a specific issue within the Corinthian church, possibly influenced by Greco-Roman cultural norms regarding women's roles.

1. Quotation-Refutation Device: Some scholars propose that Paul uses a quotation-refutation device in this passage. This means he quotes a prevailing view or statement (verses 34-35) and then refutes it (verse 36). This interpretation is supported by the structure and rhetorical style of Paul's letters.

2. Cultural Context: The instructions in verses 34-35 align with Greco-Roman cultural norms, where women were expected to be silent and submissive in public gatherings. However, Paul's broader teachings often challenge cultural norms, suggesting a more egalitarian view of women in the church⁵.

Scholarly Articles

• 1 Corinthians 14:33b-38 as a Pauline Quotation-Refutation Device (CBE International)
• The Trajectory of an Egalitarian Ethic in the Letters of Paul: The Case for Women's Ordination (Leo S. Ranzolin Jr., Pacific Union College)

NOTE: Part of this entry was generated by AI